We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

Why Your Nutella is Watery: Causes and How to Fix!

Norah Clark
Watery looking Nutella on bread

If you have opened a jar of Nutella only to discover it watery and wonering why is my Nutella watery all of a sudden? You'll be glad to hear it's a common issue that Nutella lovers encounter!

The main reason why your nutella is watery is due to temperature, incorrect storage methods, and even the age of the nutella can affect its texture!

In the following sections, you'll discover the reasons behind your watery Nutella and learn practical tips to prevent it from happening again.

So, if you're tired of your Nutella losing its dreamy texture, read on.

Why is My Nutella Watery?

Ever noticed a layer of oil on top of your beloved Nutella? It's a common question among regular Nutella consumers, and there's a quite simple explanation for it. One of the main reasons can be the natural oil separation from the hazelnuts used in the product. There is a high percentage of unsaturated fats in Nutella which come mainly from hazelnuts and palm oil.

Indeed, temperature plays a role in this process. Your Nutella might react to ambient temperature changes, especially hot weather, which causes the product to melt slightly. This melting leads to a separation of ingredients, primarily the oil in the spread. Therefore, if your jar of Nutella is kept in a warm place, you're more likely to find these watery conditions.

Moving further, storage practices impact your Nutella's consistency. Nutella's official guidelines suggest room temperature storage to maintain the ideal spreadable consistency. However, without strict temperature control, the spread may become too soft and oily.

Another significant aspect is the age of the product. As time passes, there can be a natural separating process occurring where the oils and solider ingredients differentiate. This can lead to your jar of Nutella appearing watery or oily over time, especially if not stirred up periodically.

Proper stirring helps distribute the ingredients evenly across the spread, mitigating the watery situation. While doing so, make sure to use a clean and dry spoon to prevent moisture, which can promote the growth of mold in your product.

Lastly, Nutella, like any product, can have flaws in its production. There may be instances where the product deviates somewhat from its usual consistency due to any number of production and manufacturing variables.

So, keep these factors in mind next time you open a jar of Nutella. That oil on top? Consider it a natural feature of the gourmet treat you adore. After all, it's part of what gives Nutella its unique mouth-watering creaminess. As for the tips to prevent such watery situations, we'll be covering them soon to change your Nutella game forever.

What Can Affect Nutella's Consistency

The consistency of your favorite chocolate spread, Nutella, could be affected by a number of factors. Let's search into discussing these elements and how they impact your Nutella's texture.

One of the primary causes of this wateriness is oil separation. Nutella consists of hazelnuts; and it's no secret that these nuts are naturally high in oil. Throughout time, this oil separates from the other components and rises to the surface, making the Nutella seem watery.

Another key variable stems from temperature changes. Like many confectioneries, Nutella reacts to temperature. If it's stored in places with high temperature or direct sunlight, you'll notice the texture changes. What's happening is the heat causes the oils in Nutella to melt, changing its consistency.

Next, let's consider improper storage, an easily avoidable factor. If you're not storing your Nutella correctly, you're inadvertently affecting its consistency. Leaving the lid off for extended periods allows moisture to penetrate, promoting mold growth and affecting the texture.

Finally, the age of the product can be a contributing factor. The more time Nutella spends on the shelf, the more the natural separating process occurs, affecting its original consistency.

You ask, "What can I do to maintain my Nutella's optimum consistency?" Ensuring the spread is recipient to a good old stirring before each use is one tactic. A clean spoon is a must, too, to prevent introducing moisture, which lends itself to mold growth.

Taking note of these practical tips will help you keep your Nutella at its best, prolonging its shelf life while maintaining the creamy consistency you love. It's worth noting, though, that the oil on top of your Nutella is a natural feature. Not to worry, it doesn't mean your Nutella is spoiling.

The sensation of silky Nutella gliding over your tongue is nothing short of mesmerizing. But if it's turning watery or perhaps even seeping oil, it's not just you - it's mostly because of changing temperatures.

When your jar of Nutella behaves in an unexpected way, temperature plays a starring role. A shift in the storage environment might be all it takes for your favorite hazelnut spread to lose that familiar, creamy texture.

Temperature: The Likely Culprit of Watery Nutella

Think about your actions after opening a new jar of Nutella. Do you have a habit of storing the opened jar in a fridge? If yes, then it's time for a quick change. Why? Because Nutella detests cold conditions. Interestingly, Nutella's consistency gets affected by its storage temperature.

An important point to understand is that Nutella thrives best at room temperature - around 20°C (68°F). If it's kept in colder surroundings, the oils in the spread start to harden, giving it a stiff texture. In contrast, if the temperature is too high, oils separate from the spread and rise to the top. This separation is likely why your Nutella seems watery.

Here's an interesting piece of data to illustrate the point:

Storage Temperature

Nutella Consistency

Below 20°C (68°F)

Stiff and hard

Around 20°C (68°F)

Ideal, creamy and spreadable

Above 20°C (68°F)

Oily and watery

So, the next time you're set for a Nutella binge-fest, remember to mind the temperature. And instead of a fridge, a kitchen cupboard or pantry stays just about perfect.

Storing Nutella at the Right Temperature

Storing Nutella requires nothing more than a cool, dry place - no refrigeration required. If your kitchen becomes a sauna in the summer, try finding the coolest part of your home for your Nutella hideout. Admittedly, this might seem like a lot of effort to keep a spread at optimum consistency. But for the perfect Nutella experience, it's worth every bit of it. Trust your taste buds—they'll thank you for it. After all, the joy of spreading creamy Nutella is unrivalled.

How to Keep Your Nutella Creamy

Imagine this: you're all set up for your breakfast with a hot toaster, fresh bread slices, and a jar of Nutella. But when you unscrew the cap, you discover a surprise. Instead of the creamy, dense spread you were expecting, you're greeted with a watery, undistinguished substance.

Don't fret about this unfortunate situation because there are specific methods you can use to ensure that your Nutella stays creamy. By controlling the storage conditions, you can consistently enjoy the desired texture of your Nutella. Let's explore these storage methods.

Store Nutella at Room Temperature

Everyone loves the smooth, rich texture of Nutella. To maintain this viscosity, it's important to store your Nutella jar at room temperature, ideally between 68 and 77 degrees Fahrenheit (20 and 25 degrees Celsius). This helps keep the oils in the spread at an optimum consistency, prepared for usage whenever you fancy.

Cool, Dry Place is Key

Although it might be tempting to stow your Nutella in the fridge for extended preservation, experts recommend against it. Chilled conditions can cause the oils to harden, leaving you with a stiff and unyielding spread. Instead, find a cool, dry place in your home preferably, inside a cabinet or a pantry to store your Nutella.

Avoid High Temperatures

If you live in a hot climate, it's crucial to monitor the temperature in your Nutella's storage space. Extremely high temperatures might cause oils to separate from the spread and float to the top, creating a watery layer. If the outside temperature exceeds the optimum range, you may want to look for a climate-controlled area in your house, like a wine cooler, that would provide a more consistent temperature.

Armed with these tips, you will now be able to ensure that your Nutella doesn't lose its creamy texture. It may take a little effort to control storage conditions and avoid temperature extremes, but your taste buds will appreciate the difference.

Age of the Nutella and Impact on Nutella's Texture

The age of your Nutella jar may tend to affect its texture and consistency. Like any other food product, Nutella has its own shelf life. Given the oils and processed ingredients involved, it's common for older jars to exhibit some texture changes due to the nature of oils degrading over time.

Interestingly, unopened jars of Nutella have a shelf life of approximately 1 year. This is terrific news for those who decide to stock up during a sale or simply love to have a backup jar around. Be sure to check the best-by date on the jar to ensure you're within the timeframe for optimal consumption.

An opened jar, on the other hand, might exhibit changes after just two months stored at the ideal room temperature. Of course, this isn't a hard and fast rule - it depends on the specific storage conditions.

You might be asking, "Why is my Nutella watery if I stored it in cool dry place as recommended?" Your answer likely lies in the age of the opened jar and it isn't unexpected as contents might separate after some time.

If your Nutella becomes watery, you still have options. Rather than tossing it out, you can try to stir the spread. Stirring thoroughly should reincorporate the oils and other ingredients, returning the spread to its creamy, smooth texture.

Temperatures over 77°F may quicken the separation process, so if you live in a warm area, be mindful of where your Nutella is stored. As previously mentioned, it's a good idea to store in a climate-controlled area if living in a hot climate.

Now you've got more insights about the factors affecting Nutella's texture and how to ensure your spread stays scrumptious every time you dip into it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does age affect Nutella's texture and consistency?

Yes, the age of Nutella can impact its texture due to the degradation of oils over time. It's advised to stir the spread if changes are noticed.

What is the shelf life of unopened Nutella jars?

Unopened jars of Nutella have a shelf life of approximately one year. After opening, noticeable changes might appear after two months.

Can the texture of Nutella be returned to normal if it becomes watery?

Yes, stirring the Nutella spread can help reincorporate the degraded oils, returning the texture back to its creamy state.

Does temperature impact the separation process in Nutella?

Yes, temperatures above 77°F can quicken the oil separation process in Nutella. It is therefore advised to store it in a climate-controlled area in hot climates.

Summary of Why Your Nutella is Watery

So, you've learned that watery Nutella isn't a cause for alarm. It's simply a matter of the oils separating over time or due to high temperatures.

If you've got an old jar or live in a hot climate, this is likely the reason behind your runny spread. Remember, you can always stir it up to get that creamy consistency back.

Keep your Nutella stored in a cool place to avoid this in the future. Don't let a little oil separation stop you from enjoying your favorite spread. Now, go forth and enjoy that delicious, creamy Nutella just the way you like it.

Profile Image Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, Editor of Boyd Hampers! Norah is a food writer with over a decade of experience in hospitality as a pastry chef, sous chef, and barista; former chef at the Savoy Hotel, Ritz Carlton, Four Seasons and Plaza Hotel.

Back to Boyd Hampers Magazine

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

1 of 4