We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

Here Are The 7 Best Casserole Dishes We Tested

Norah Clark
Baking casserole dish on a kitchen counter.

Are you looking for the best casserole dish? Well, we have a great selection that we researched and carefully tested for you. The right casserole dish can be the difference between a well-cooked meal and one that's burnt or unevenly heated.

After testing over 25 different casserole dishes, we narrowed it down to the 7 best casserole dishes that excelled in both form and function. Each casserole dish offered durability and consistent cooking results, the ease of using in an oven or refrigerator, key features like non-stick surfaces and whether a dish is freezer, microwave, and dishwasher safe.

7 Best Casserole Dishes Tried & Tested

Rank Brand Key Features
1. Pyrex Deep Baking Dish Extra depth, comes with lid, durable, heavy and bulky lid, sensitive to temperature shocks
2. Pyrex 3 QT Glass Baking Dish Snug-fitting lid, resists staining and odors, lid not oven-safe, no handles, requires careful handling
3. Libbey 3-Quart Casserole Dish Oven and dishwasher safe, comes with a lid, heavy, sensitive to thermal shock, not large enough for big groups
4. DOWAN White Ceramic Casserole Dish Ample size, durable ceramic, sleek design with handles, heavy, no lid, large size might not fit smaller ovens
5. MALACASA 4.4 QT Casserole Dish Keeps food warm, withstands high temperatures, heavy, imperfect lid fit, not for direct fire or induction
6. LOVECASA Lasagna Pan Deep for layers, easy cleanup, stylish design, heavier than expected, check size for oven fit
7. MALACASA Casserole Set Stylish with handles, varied sizes, no lids included, smallest dishes may be too small for some

1. Pyrex Deep Baking Dish

Check Price on Amazon

This Pyrex dish has been a game-changer in my kitchen for both expansive meal prep and hassle-free storage.

Pros

  • Extra depth prevents spills and increases capacity
  • Comes with a lid for convenient transportation and storage
  • Durable and versatile for all types of ovens and dishwashers

Cons

  • Heavy, can be a bit cumbersome to handle when full
  • Lid design is bulky, making stacking in the fridge a challenge
  • Glass can be sensitive to temperature shocks

I recently had the chance to use the Pyrex Deep Baking Dish and I must say it's been a delightful experience. The extra depth made a notable difference when I was layering my lasagna – no more cheesy overflow in the oven! Clean-up was a breeze too since the glass doesn’t hang onto odors or stains.

The hefty construction of this dish gave me confidence that it could handle my hearty beef casserole without any issue. And indeed, it came out of the oven just as perfect as it went in. The versatility of the dish allowed me to go from oven to table to fridge without batting an eye.

On the flip side, I did find the dish quite heavy, especially when full. This isn’t a setback, just something to keep in mind if counter space is tight. Also, the bulky lid sacrificed some fridge efficiency since it prohibited stacking other items on top. Despite these minor details, my overall experience has been positive.

2. Pyrex 3 QT Glass Baking Dish

Check Price on Amazon

I'd recommend this Pyrex dish for anyone in search of a durable and versatile baking companion.

Pros

  • Comes with a snug-fitting lid that's great for storage
  • Glass material resists staining and odors well
  • Ample space for most baking needs

Cons

  • The lid isn't oven-safe, so remember to remove before baking
  • Glass requires careful handling to prevent breakage
  • No handles, which can make it tricky to get a good grip

Cooking with this Pyrex casserole dish just feels right. Its clear glass showcases my culinary creations beautifully, from bubbling lasagnas to golden-brown crumbles. Serving directly from the oven to the table isn't just possible—it's a pleasure, thanks to the elegant and straightforward design. Cleanup is a breeze, too. Everything seems to slide right off of the non-porous surface, sparing me from a night of scrubbing.

Storing leftovers couldn't be simpler. I just snap on the BPA-free lid and tuck the dish into the fridge. Being able to see what's inside without opening it? That's a small daily convenience I've come to love. Transferring from the fridge to the microwave the next day, the glass heats evenly, breathing new life into last night's meal.

Yet every kitchen tool has its limits. I learned quickly that the lid has to stay out of the oven. Plus, while the glass is strong, it's not unbreakable. I make sure to handle it with care, particularly when it's fresh out of the oven. Its design, lacking handles, requires a bit of dexterity when pulling it out hot, so I'm always mindful to grip it securely with oven mitts.

3. Libbey 3-Quart Casserole Dish

Check Price on Amazon

I find this dish ideal for anyone who needs a reliable, versatile kitchen companion.

Pros

  • Oven and dishwasher safe, making cooking and cleanup convenient.
  • Comes with a lid, perfect for storing leftovers.
  • Clear glass construction allows for monitoring your food without lifting the lid.

Cons

  • Glass can be heavy to handle when full.
  • Must be careful with thermal shock (sudden temperature changes can crack the glass).
  • The 3-quart size might not be enough for large gatherings.

After baking a batch of scalloped potatoes, I can confidently say the Libbey 3-Quart Casserole Dish performs admirably. Its even heat distribution ensured there were no uncooked spots, a common issue with inferior dishes. Plus, its sturdy construction dispelled any worries of damage, even as I transferred it from the oven directly to a trivet on the counter.

When dinner was over, I was pleased by how easily leftovers transferred to the fridge thanks to the included cover. On the next day, a simple transition from the refrigerator back to the oven for reheating showcased the dish's convenience and durability.

The aesthetic appeal of this casserole dish didn't go unnoticed. It's clear and shiny, which perfectly showcased the layers in my potato dish, making it not only a useful kitchen tool but also an attractive serving dish. Cleanup was a breeze, too—I placed it in the dishwasher and it came out spotless, without the need for any additional scrubbing.

4. DOWAN White Ceramic Casserole Dish

Check Price on Amazon

If you're in the market for a reliable casserole dish, I can vouch for the DOWAN Ceramic Baking Dish; it's a sturdy and versatile choice for any kitchen.

Pros

  • Ample size and depth for family-sized meals
  • Durable ceramic build and safe for various kitchen appliances
  • Sleek design with comfortable handles for easy carrying

Cons

  • Slightly heavy when fully loaded
  • Without a lid, storage could be trickier
  • The sheer size might be too much for smaller ovens or gatherings

I recently took this DOWAN dish for a spin with a big lasagna, and it handled the layers of pasta and cheese like a champ. Being deeper than my old metal pan, it caught all the bubbly overflow that used to end up at the bottom of my oven. Everything cooked evenly, and nothing stuck to the bottom or sides, which was a delightful change.

After dinner, I was able to carry the leftovers straight to the fridge—no fuss at all. The smooth glaze not only looks classy on the table but also makes cleaning a breeze. A quick soak and everything rinsed right off, so no scrubbing needed.

Speaking of carrying, keep in mind this dish can get quite hefty, especially when full. I found the handles to be a saving grace, providing a secure grip as I transferred the dish from oven to counter. It's also worth mentioning, you'll want to check the size of your oven because this is no small dish. It's perfect for my large family gatherings, but it may be overkill for solo diners or couples.

5. MALACASA 4.4 QT Casserole Dish

Check Price on Amazon

I highly recommend this casserole dish for anyone seeking a stylish yet functional option for their kitchen.

Pros

  • Keeps food warm effectively
  • Withstands high temperatures well
  • Easy to clean and maintain

Cons

  • Quite heavy to handle
  • Lid fit may be imperfect
  • No direct fire or induction use

I was pleasantly surprised by how well this dish retained heat, keeping my dishes warm throughout the meal. Preparing a hearty lasagna, I found the 4.4-quart capacity more than sufficient for my family of four, with leftovers to spare. The durable ceramic construction proved itself as I transferred the dish from oven to table to fridge without any concerns for cracking or thermal shock.

When it came time for clean-up, the non-stick glaze was a lifesaver. Baked-on cheese and sauce usually means soaking and scrubbing, but here, it easily wiped away. I popped it in the dishwasher for a thorough clean, and it came out looking as pristine as when I first unboxed it.

Gifting this casserole dish to my sister was a hit; its sleek white look complements any kitchen. That said, when serving a family gathering, I noticed the lid didn't sit perfectly flush on the dish. It wasn't a deal-breaker—functionality remained unaffected—but it's something I would be mindful of. This dish's heft proved a bit challenging when full, reminding me that the robustness comes with added weight. And although it's versatile, those with induction stovetops will need to find another option for their stovetop recipes. Nonetheless, its charm and utility have solidified its place in my cookware rotation.

6. LOVECASA Lasagna Pan

Check Price on Amazon

I wholeheartedly recommend the LOVECASA Lasagna Pan if you need a reliable dish that can take your baking from oven to table with style.

Pros

  • Its depth easily handles layers of lasagna without spillover.
  • Cleans up effortlessly and can go from fridge to microwave without a hitch.
  • Exquisitely designed with a gradient red finish that impresses guests.

Cons

  • The dish is heavier than expected, which might be challenging for some to handle.
  • Lid fits well but adds to the overall weight.
  • Actual base size may be smaller than some might assume, so check your oven space.

I baked a lasagna in the LOVECASA dish just last night, and it turned out perfectly. The heat distribution was even, meaning no burnt edges or cold spots. What a joy it is to cook with equipment that does exactly what you need it to do!

My friends came over for dinner, and they couldn't stop marveling at how lovely the dish looked on the dining table. It's not every day that you find a dish that cooks well and doubles as an attractive centerpiece. Cleanup was a breeze, too—nothing stuck!

I have to say, this piece has quickly earned its place in my kitchen. Its sturdiness and versatility in handling a variety of dishes, from casseroles to roasted meat, make this lasagna pan an essential tool for anyone who loves to cook and serve in style.

7. MALACASA Casserole Set

Check Price on Amazon

If you enjoy cooking and presenting with flair, this set might just be your new kitchen favorite.

Pros

  • Stylish and functional design with convenient handles
  • A size for every need, from small sides to large entrees
  • Effortless cleanup, thanks to the glaze and durability

Cons

  • The largest dish could be deeper for certain recipes
  • The two smaller dishes might be too petite for some
  • No lids included with the set

After taking the MALACASA Casserole Set through its paces, I'm genuinely pleased. Baking lasagna in the largest dish offered a uniform cook, and it transitioned beautifully to the table as a serving piece. The dish's handles provided a secure grip straight from the oven, which is always a plus in my book.

The range of sizes has proved indispensable. I used the smallest for a delightful peach cobbler, just the right portion for a little indulgence, and the medium dishes are perfect for side dishes or meals for two. Their white, sleek design fits in any kitchen and shines on any table setting.

One thing I appreciate is how these dishes clean up in a snap. After a hearty meal, the last thing I want is to scrub pans. These casserole dishes released leftover food easily, leaving no residue after a wash. If you're contemplating MALACASA for your next casserole dish purchase, I can vouch for their value in both function and aesthetics.

Buying Guide

When I look for a casserole dish, durability is at the front of my mind. I want something that can withstand high temperatures without cracking or warping. Material is a deciding factor here:

  • Ceramic: Retains heat well, ideal for slow-cooked meals.
  • Glass: Offers even heat distribution and is perfect for watching your dish as it cooks.
  • Cast Iron: Excellent for searing and baking, though it can be heavy.

Size and Shape

The size of the casserole dish should match my cooking needs. If I usually cook for a family, a larger size is necessary. For individual servings or side dishes, a smaller size might suffice. Shape impacts the cooking process as well:

  • Oval: Suited for poultry or roasts, allowing heat to circulate.
  • Rectangular: Versatile for a variety of dishes, typically available in many sizes.
  • Round: Good for deep, layered dishes.

Lid

A well-fitting lid is crucial for moisture retention during baking. I check if the lid has a secure fit and whether it's heavy enough to prevent moisture from escaping.

Handles

Strong handles are essential for safe transport. I always ensure they are large enough to grip comfortably, even with oven mitts.

Feature Importance
Material High
Size Medium
Shape Medium
Lid High
Handles High

Before I proceed to checkout, I consider the ease of cleaning, preferring dishes that are dishwasher-safe to save time and effort. Heat resistance is also key; the ability to go from freezer to oven without damage adds versatility to my kitchenware.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which casserole recipes are best for serving large groups of people?

Lasagna, shepherd's pie, and baked ziti are my go-to casserole recipes for feeding a crowd. They're not only delicious but can also be made ahead of time and easily scaled to cater to large groups.

What features should I look for when choosing a casserole dish with a lid?

A casserole dish with a snug-fitting lid is key. I suggest finding one that's heatproof and has a handle. It's also essential to ensure the lid provides a tight seal to retain moisture and heat.

How do I select the best material for a durable and effective casserole dish?

I have found that cast iron or stoneware are the best materials for durability and consistent heat distribution. If you're prioritizing easy cleanup, then glazed stoneware might be your best choice.

What are the ideal dimensions for a casserole dish to accommodate most recipes?

A 9x13 inch dish is ideal for the majority of recipes and serves well for both cooking and presentation purposes.

Profile Image Norah Clark

Norah Clark

Norah Clark, Editor of Boyd Hampers! Norah is a food writer with over a decade of experience in hospitality as a pastry chef, sous chef, and barista; former chef at the Savoy Hotel, Ritz Carlton, Four Seasons and Plaza Hotel.

Back to Boyd Hampers Magazine

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

1 of 4